Since succeeding her dearly departed husband, Bill, to become Jasper County's first female sheriff, Mary Beth Cain has closed more cases than any three of her male predecessors combined. But nobody bats a thousand in the cop game. Nobody. And, ovaries aside, Mary Beth knows she's no different. There'd been a handful of unsolveds during her tenure, victims and families denied their justice, and each and every one of them gnaws at her soul. She thinks about them late at night as she sips her whiskey, counting regrets like sheep.

But the case that haunts Mary Beth most is one that went cold before she was even on the force: the long-ago disappearance of a family friend, named Maria Ruiz. So when a country psychic's vision leads to the discovery of Maria's body, Mary Beth isn't willing to chalk it up as genuine clairvoyance and goes all in on an investigation that cuts close to home.