Kaitlyn Watson messed up bad. An old high-school friend of hers took blackmail videos of her and her girlfriend, Wednesday Newland (part-time witch, full-time nerd, and all-around bedroom genius) and Kaitlyn didn’t tell Wednesday about it. The whole thing ended with Wednesday almost getting killed by an incubus (she got better).

Kaitlyn knows she needs to be punished, and Wednesday agrees that Kaitlyn has to learn to trust her more. And what better way to combine a punishment and a lesson than to invite Wednesday’s ex-girlfriend Pixel up for a weekend? The two of them can invent torments and humiliations for Kaitlyn even more fiendish than the ones Wednesday comes up with herself, and the sight of Wednesday and Pixel together while Kaitlyn is relegated to the corner is enough to make her regret everything she’s ever done.

Kaitlyn loves it and hates it at the same time. But will she trust Wednesday enough to let her know when enough is enough?