Falling in love for the first time is beautiful, but falling in love with two people at the same time is confusing.It's 2007. Seth Harris is an angry high school senior, struggling to keep motivated after his parents divorce. With a dream of becoming an author some day, Seth would rather write than do homework. He falls in love for the first time when Tessa Copeland, an equally unmotivated senior with a rebellious streak, distracts him from his crumbling world. Everyone sees the negative impact Tessa has on him, and they tell him to leave her. However, there's one thing he'll never do: turn out like his mother and leave the one he loves. But if he keeps throwing his future away for her, he won't graduate high school.When the studious Marie Burn stumbles into his life, the confident fellow writer inspires Seth to be a better guy. The problem? He has to fight his growing feelings for Marie in order to hold onto his relationship with Tessa. Will Seth learn how to let go of the one he is stubbornly committed to and give real love a chance, or will he let something good slip through his fingers with the flick of a graduation cap?