It's Christmastime in Sugarcreek and Cheryl Miller has a lot left to accomplish if she is going to be ready in time for Christmas Day. However, her to-do list takes a back seat when she learns that there have been several thefts in the area. And when the Swiss Miss gift shop is hit next, she knows she can't sit back and wait for the thief to be caught.

Meanwhile, Cheryl's daughter, Rebecca, has claimed to have been visited by an angel-more than once. Cheryl tries to reason with her daughter and get to the truth behind Rebecca's story, but the little girl refuses to offer any other explanation.

With her mystery-solving sidekick and mother-in-law, Naomi, by her side, surely Cheryl can find answers to both mysteries before the holidays arrive!