Father Peter is the beloved parish priest of Brotherton village. But when allegations of misconduct mysteriously surface against him, his parishioners are thrown into turmoil. What should they believe?

Father Peter's own faith starts to crumble when a close priest friend commits suicide. Then bizarre circumstances throw him together with Matt Goldworth, a non-believer.

Matt finds himself helping a clergyman of the very Church he despises, and discovering a solution to the mystery no one could have foreseen.