After spending nearly twenty years searching for his runaway high school girlfriend Alice, Mike Connors, a man with a bottle for a crutch, returns to Fallen's Island. He intends to clean up his life and let go of the past, only the past won't let go of him. His old high school friends are still there and are telling Mike all sorts of lies about Alice making it difficult for him to give up his addiction. The relationship with his mom, who has been slowly deteriorating, is as strained as the day he left. Then the hauntings begin and Mike learns how everything truly leads back to Alice.