Someone had tainted the sugar at the newly opened Café Caffé coffeehouse in the village of Eastport. A dozen locals got seriously ill and one died. Nora Huggins- mother wife mystery buff and want-to-be sleuth-couldnt help but to get involved. Her delving into the crime led her to believe that it had been a nasty youthful prank. Two of the villages old spinster sisters Winnie and Ginnie Miller were among those who fell victim to the tainted sugar. However when Winnie suddenly died surviving Ginnie chose not to hold the coffeehouse responsible. Because of the Miller sisters reputation for being uncharitable Nora became suspicious and probed deeper into their affairs ultimately discovering that Winnie may have in fact been murdered. Proving it became a delicate matter for Nora and the local police chief.