Case Larson is restless. Although he has a loving boyfriend, contractor Ray Burch, he often feels neglected in their relationship because Ray is too busy with work to spend time with him. So Case decides to spend a little time with Luke Mills, a handsome guy from his gym. Case's hookups with Luke help calm his restlessness and feed his need for the attention he's not getting from Ray. But Ray finds out about Case's cheating and their relationship implodes.

Case quickly realizes he made a huge mistake and tries to repair the damage he's done. But making things right with Ray means cutting ties with Luke, a job easier said than done. Luke refuses to go away quietly and he's determined to make Case pay for using him.

Case goes from having a stud to a stalker in his life, and he has to find a way to stop the harassment, win his boyfriend back, and maintain his sanity all at the same time.