After her roommate moves out, Paige Latimer finds a deck of tarot cards in her apartment. It seems like the perfect side hustle for her busy life. She manages to score her first gig at an office party, where she does a reading for Saul Wexler.

Saul, an aging yet still attractive insurance salesman, is desperately trying to seek some sort of guidance as his wife dies of cancer. As Saul addresses the cards, he rediscovers his lost sense of sexuality, gone during years of chemo treatments for his wife. He also finds himself falling for Paige in all the ways he does not want, especially as his wife remains alive.

When Paige's business takes off, she leaves behind everything she thought she knew about the everyday world, including what to do when she also starts to fall for Saul. Their attraction reaches an apex on Halloween, the time when the barriers between the worlds are the thinnest.

Can Saul continue to live his life by other people's guidelines and blot out his own feelings? Will Paige continue to predict the lives of others while ignoring herself? Both turn to the cards to see if love, regardless of any barriers, is worthwhile.